
Yes, climate mitigation costs money. So it’s understandable that South Africa would want to pay less. But if you go through what South Africa wants at COP31 (not that it’s necessarily going to get it), much of it sounds like a plea to carry on just as it is because it doesn’t have the money.
That’s a rather crass viewpoint.
Let’s be clear. All the sophisticated language and diplomatic explanations boil down to one thing, particularly with this crowd: get something for nothing. Money for nothing. That’s what they want.
The dominant political party has some explaining to do. As Sunday Times columnist Barney Mthombothi wrote in his column yesterday, it has let down the poor for more than 30 years. It’s a damning assessment, but one that is difficult to dismiss.
And yet the party remains the country’s biggest political force, despite everything. The political establishment seems remarkably adept at finding new ways to spend money while explaining why it needs more of it.
Now the begging bowl is out again, this time on the international stage.
COP31, the 31st United Nations climate conference, is taking place in Antalya, Türkiye, from 9 to 20 November. South Africa has joined other developing countries in pressing wealthy nations to provide substantially more climate finance.
Among its demands are more money for climate adaptation, replenishment of international climate funds and additional support for countries dealing with the damage caused by climate change. It also wants adaptation finance tripled by 2035.
The argument is that developing countries cannot be expected to shoulder the costs of climate mitigation and adaptation when the industrialised world has been responsible for such a large proportion of historical greenhouse gas emissions.
Wealthier countries supposedly have greater financial resources and carry a substantial historical responsibility for emissions. Developing countries also face problems in adapting to floods, droughts, water shortages and other consequences of a changing climate.
But there is another side to this argument.
How much responsibility do individual governments have for managing their own economies, spending taxpayers’ money sensibly and creating the conditions for economic growth? How long can a country keep pointing to its lack of resources while failing to address the waste, corruption and inefficiency that drain those resources in the first place?
South Africa needs around R3.7-trillion to implement its climate ambitions, according to government estimates. That’s a staggering amount of money. The question is not simply how much other countries should contribute, but how effectively South Africa will use whatever funding it receives.
There is also a broader political question about these international gatherings. The language of climate justice, historical responsibility, adaptation and just transitions can become a convenient vehicle for governments to demand financial assistance without necessarily confronting their own shortcomings.
I am not suggesting that every developing country is in the same position or that climate finance is unnecessary. Far from it. But there is a difference between legitimate financial assistance and an expectation that somebody else should continually pick up the bill.
Interestingly, my last experience of one of these climate conferences was COP17 in Durban in 2011.
That meeting was considered an important milestone in international climate negotiations. It produced the Durban Platform, which paved the way for the Paris Agreement four years later. It was a significant achievement, even if the actual business of reducing emissions has proved considerably more difficult.
It’s quite astounding how the years have passed. Yet, when you look at the issues dominating COP31, there is a familiar ring to much of the discussion.
Climate finance, developing countries demanding more assistance, disagreements over who should pay, the transition away from fossil fuels, and arguments about how much responsibility should fall on wealthy nations.
Fifteen years on, we’re still having much the same conversation.
Despite my criticism of the political posturing, I don’t believe these conferences are unnecessary. Climate change is a global problem. Emissions don’t respect national borders, and what one country does, or fails to do, can have consequences for others. With nearly 200 countries involved, COP provides an essential international forum for governments to negotiate common objectives, assess progress and hold one another accountable.
The trouble is that these gatherings are as much about politics as they are about climate change. Countries arrive with their own economic interests, political priorities and domestic problems. Some want to protect their fossil-fuel industries, others want to accelerate the transition to renewable energy, while many want somebody else to finance the changes they need to make. South Africa must get its own house in order rather than continually expecting the rest of the world to pick up the bill.
Editorial Disclosure & Disclaimer
Financial News Daily is an independent business news syndicate and a wholly owned subsidiary of Idea Accelerator. We publish financial, environmental and corporate commentary for digital platforms, media outlets and organisations. Nothing published here constitutes investment, legal or financial advice. All opinions are editorial commentary on matters of public and economic interest.









