
I watched the TikTok videos about the new ProNutro formulation with some scepticism at first. Social media outrage can sometimes become theatre. People pile on because everyone else is piling on. But the complaints kept coming. Some said it tasted nothing like the old ProNutro. Others were far harsher, saying it was revolting and that even their dogs wouldn’t eat it.
So I thought I’d see what the fuss was about for myself.
Finding the new ProNutro wasn’t easy. I could only locate stock at Woolworths, where it was, naturally, more expensive. One staff member told me she actually preferred the new one to the old version. That surprised me.
I had it for breakfast yesterday morning and, unfortunately, the critics were right. The taste is completely different. The old ProNutro had a familiar, comforting flavour. This version feels oddly hollow, as if it can’t decide what it wants to be. The texture is even worse. The old ProNutro was smooth. This was lumpy despite adding enough milk. It also tasted much sweeter than I remember. Far too sweet.
My rating? Zero out of ten.
This is not a product people seem to want. Judging by the outrage online, many consumers feel as if something they grew up with has been tampered with in a laboratory somewhere by people who neither understand nor care about what made it popular in the first place. Hence the headline: “Frankenstein” product.
Apparently there are reports of recalls and shortages, but I honestly don’t know what’s going on because shelves also seemed oddly empty of Weet-Bix in some stores. Usually when manufacturers face a backlash of this scale, the silence becomes noticeable. Then the PR statements arrive: vague, polished, and carefully worded so nobody actually says anything meaningful.
The sad part is that I now have a box of ProNutro sitting in the kitchen with no obvious destination. I can’t even give it to dogs because, according to some people online, even dogs are refusing it.
But the bigger issue here is not just breakfast cereal. It’s what’s happening to South African brands in general.
Pioneer Foods, now owned by PepsiCo, seems to be meddling with products that South Africans have known for generations. I still don’t fully understand why PepsiCo bought Pioneer Foods in the first place. A global cooldrink and snack giant owning deeply local pantry brands always felt like an awkward fit.
And people have short memories.
A few years ago, Peck’s Anchovette was effectively dumped by Pioneer Food, owned by PepsiCo. Thankfully, Pick n Pay and Cape-Gulf Brands rescued the products, recipes, and machinery. South Africans still have Peck’s Anchovette largely because local people stepped in before those brands disappeared into corporate oblivion.
That’s the concern now. What goes next?
Will Weet-Bix eventually be “reformulated” too? Will Marmite be altered beyond recognition? Marmite is one of those products woven into South African kitchens over decades. There is no real substitute for it.
Peck’s Anchovette, packed for Cape-Gulf Brands in Saldanha is an old South African pantry staple. What happens when products like this eventually land on the desk of somebody in a foreign boardroom looking at spreadsheets instead of customers?
I remember years ago when CPC International owned some of these brands. I was involved in work connected to fighting off Skippy peanut butter in South Africa. Look what happened there. Skippy disappeared. Another American giant arrived with confidence and assumptions about consumer tastes, only to discover that local eating habits are deeply rooted and not easily replaced.
That is the lesson many multinational corporations still don’t seem to grasp. You can introduce foreign products successfully, absolutely. South Africans are adventurous consumers. But start tampering with established local favourites at your peril.
Because local taste is not just flavour. It’s memory. It’s routine. It’s childhood. It’s identity.
And while big corporations chase efficiencies, reformulations, and global standardisation, smaller local manufacturers are quietly thriving because they actually understand the people buying the products.
In Cape Town, KwaZulu-Natal, Gauteng, Pretoria, Aeroton, Alberton and elsewhere, smaller food makers are producing fantastic biscuits, chips, snacks, sauces and sweets that people genuinely love. They understand the South African palate instinctively. Most importantly, they are giving a hammering to the more pricey local manufacturing brands that have been around for decades and now are charging super high prices.
Take Go Slow chips, a new brand from a small manufacturer. ?The name is accurate. You should go slow with them because once you open the packet it becomes very difficult to stop.
Ironically, one of the few products in the Pioneer Foods stable that I still genuinely enjoy is their chutney. I find it fruitier and less sugary than Mrs Ball’s. But now I even wonder about that. Will somebody in a boardroom decide South Africans want it sweeter, sharper, cheaper, or “more globally aligned”?
Because that increasingly seems to be the problem. Everything is being adjusted, standardised, Americanised, optimised.
And consumers notice.
There’s a big lesson here for marketers and manufacturers. South Africans will happily embrace some foreign brands and products. But when it comes to long-standing local favourites, leave them alone.










