
I read an interesting article in the New York Times recently about private equity firms investing in popular restaurant chains and independent food brands. The article highlighted an interesting dilemma: customers were concerned that once these businesses came under private equity ownership, they would lose the very qualities that had made them popular in the first place.
It’s a legitimate concern. A restaurant that has built its reputation on good food, personal service and a distinctive atmosphere isn’t necessarily going to improve when someone decides to turn it into a national chain.
The private equity argument, of course, is that these investments provide businesses with the capital and management expertise they need to expand. Founders get an opportunity to realise the value of their businesses, while investors get an opportunity to grow them and eventually sell at a profit.
In theory, everybody wins.
To be fair, private equity doesn’t always end in disaster. There are businesses that have benefited enormously from an injection of capital, improved management and the opportunity to expand.
Take The Beverage Company (BevCo), for example. In 2014, Nedbank Private Equity invested in Little Green Beverages, a relatively small Eastern Cape soft-drink manufacturer producing the Refreshhh brand. With financial backing, the business acquired Quality Beverages in Cape Town, which produced Jive, and Shoreline Beverages in KwaZulu-Natal, maker of Coo-ee.
What started as a regional operation grew into a national beverage group. In 2026, Nedbank Private Equity completed its exit by selling its stake to India’s Varun Beverages. This is a good example of private equity doing what it is supposed to do: providing the capital and resources to help a smaller business expand into something considerably bigger.
But not every story has such a happy ending.
South Africa has had its fair share of private equity disasters. Edcon, which once owned Edgars, Jet and CNA, is probably the most prominent example. Bain Capital’s heavily debt-funded acquisition in 2007 left the retailer struggling under an enormous financial burden. Bain eventually exited, and Edcon went into business rescue in 2020.
Ascendis Health is another cautionary tale. An aggressive acquisition strategy, financed largely through debt, eventually left the company in a financial mess, with lenders taking control of important assets.
But I’ve also come across smaller private equity investments that tell a rather different story.
In one case, a small business chain received an injection of private capital. Management subsequently took over, and over time the business lost much of the ethos that had made it successful. One of its operations is still surviving, while another was eventually acquired by a different company. Neither, however, is quite what it was in its former days.
Private equity investors frequently bring in their own management teams. Suddenly, a relatively straightforward business finds itself with a new layer of executives, consultants and professional managers, some of whom have little practical experience of running that particular type of operation.
And so the bright-eyed accountants arrive. They have management titles, impressive salaries, luxury company cars and, in some instances, rather impressive offices to go with them. There is plenty of corporate activity, plenty of meetings and plenty of people telling everyone else how the business should be run.
Unfortunately, understanding the numbers on a spreadsheet and understanding a business are two different things.
You can have the best financial models, the most impressive management credentials and an expensive corporate headquarters, but none of these guarantees that you understand your customers, your employees or the business’s competitive advantage.
Sometimes the people who know the business best are the very people who get pushed aside.
The danger is that management becomes more concerned with reporting to investors, meeting financial targets and justifying their own positions than with the business itself. Costs are cut, established practices are changed and the character of the business gradually disappears.
And while the new management team might look rather impressive on paper, the business doesn’t necessarily perform any better. In some cases, it goes backwards.
The New York Times article raises an interesting question about whether private equity can expand a beloved restaurant brand without destroying its character. The answer is probably yes, provided the investors understand what made the business successful in the first place and are prepared to protect it.
But there is a bigger issue here. Private equity investors ultimately want a return on their investment. They aren’t buying a business simply because they love its products, its people or its reputation. They have an exit strategy, and at some point they want to sell.
That doesn’t make them villains. It’s simply how the business model works.
The trouble starts when the investment strategy becomes more important than the business.
So, if you hear that a private equity firm is coming in to rescue, restructure or turn around a business you know and value, don’t automatically assume that this is good news.
It might be. But I’d be watching rather carefully to see who arrives in the new management team, what happens to the people who built the business and whether anyone is actually paying attention to the customers.
If the first thing you see is a new corporate headquarters, a fleet of expensive cars and a collection of executives with impressive titles, I’d be inclined to worry.
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/10/20/dining/private-equity-restaurant-deals.html
Editorial Disclosure & Disclaimer
Financial News Daily is an independent business news syndicate and a wholly owned subsidiary of Idea Accelerator. We publish financial, environmental and corporate commentary for digital platforms, media outlets and organisations. Nothing published here constitutes investment, legal or financial advice. All opinions are editorial commentary on matters of public and economic interest.
