
It is painful to remember the good from the past.
In the 1980s, you could walk into the Rosebank Mall, or later on, the branch in Fourways Mall, and find an Edgars store. In those stores, you could find excellent clothes—particularly if you were a man. They had a truly outstanding range of shoes. I can’t remember all the brand names now, but that is exactly where I bought mine. It was the place where you went when you needed to buy a proper suit and tie.
Then there was Stuttafords, an even older institution than Edgars, known for generations as the “Harrods of South Africa”. Today, there are none left in the country. The last one I remember was in the Cresta Center.
It was tragic when the final South African Stuttafords stores closed their doors for good in August 2017. Today, only one lone, independent survivor remains across the border in Windhoek, Namibia, operating out of The Grove Mall.
The Silent corporate “Warts-and-All”
The trouble with these corporate stories is that you rarely get to the absolute truth. When a company is doing well, you get plenty of polished corporate “upward” stories. The one that comes to mind is Larger Than Life, the story of Liberty Life’s founder Donald Gordon, beautifully written by that excellent, dignified business writer Ken Romain back in 1989. It laid out the details of Gordon’s formidable life, but it was still an authorized corporate biography.
The only book I can think of that showed the true “warts and all” of a corporate demise was On a Clear Day You Can See General Motors, written by Detroit journalist J. Patrick Wright about John DeLorean. DeLorean actually tried to block the book’s publication for years because it got too close to the bone. It is precisely because those books get near the truth that they are so excellent.
You can find a number of brilliant books written on the demise of department stores in America, Great Britain, and Europe—but you won’t find a detailed post-mortem like that for our own lost giants here in South Africa.
A Nostalgia for Grand Spaces
I suppose I hold a deep nostalgia for those old department stores. You could find absolutely anything you wanted in them. For the ladies, there were those massive, glamorous perfume counters and racks of luxury clothing.
The decline of institutions like Edgars, Stuttafords, and even CNA—which has virtually vanished from our malls after entering business rescue in 2021—was driven by complex forces. The political and economic transition of the mid-1990s changed our demographics and shopping patterns rapidly. Then came global shocks like the 2008 financial crisis. With the local currency taking a heavy hammering, the cost of importing high-end brands for these department stores simply became too expensive.
Yet, some smaller department stores stubbornly soldier on.
Down in Fish Hoek, we have AP Jones. It actually started in 1928—making it a year older than Edgars itself! It is just a single store catering to a very small, loyal local consumer base. They recently revamped the space to keep it relevant for modern times. It’s a tough environment, and when family-run businesses eventually pass down through the generations, you always wonder what will happen.
But the family keeps AP Jones going because of a deep-seated pride and history. In fact, the founder, Albert Pascoe Jones, actually worked for Garlicks before opening his own shop! Can you believe that? Garlicks was another legendary department store of the Cape. The very last Garlicks store closed its doors in Cape Town in February 1993, over three decades ago.
The Soul of the Store
Let’s be clear: the old Edgars and Stuttafords stores were top-notch. I have been into famous department stores in the UK, Sweden, Switzerland, and France, but nothing quite compared to the feeling of walking into those grand, flagship Edgars and Stuttafords branches in their prime. They were special, and they catered beautifully to the well-heeled top end of the market.
Of course, if you wanted to buy a decent, everyday suit years ago, you could go to Woolworths in Sandton City for a much cheaper price. But if you really wanted to look dashing, you had to go to Edgars or Stuttafords. Yes, the early 1980s had plenty of fantastic boutique men’s shops in downtown Johannesburg and great clothing stores in Hillbrow, but they were small. Nothing matched the sheer scale and presence of the big department stores.
Part of the tragedy of Edgars—and particularly CNA—was the arrival of global private equity giants like Bain Capital. They saddled these businesses with immense debt to finance their buyouts. That is the inherent risk of private equity; they take ownership of a brand, but they don’t always understand the unique soul of running a retail operation on the ground.
When I was reporting on business in the early 1980s, Edgars was owned by South African Breweries (SAB). The CEO back then was Sydney Press—a legendary pioneer of South African retail whose name many have now forgotten. Under his steady hand, the heart of the empire beat at their famous head office, Edgar Dale, south of Johannesburg.
Now, I see that Edgars is embarking on a new expansion program. But these won’t be the sprawling, multi-level retail palaces of old. They are opening smaller, fit-for-purpose community stores. They still have about 100 mainline stores, and they even plan to roll out cellular formats. How well those will work in today’s landscape remains to be seen, but it is happening.
It is heartening news that Edgars is still alive, fighting, and adapting. Hats off to them, and let’s hope they make a great go of it in what is a very tough South African market.









