Should you tip even if the service is poor?

Share these new ideas
Photo: Unsplash

Tipping—one of life’s little dilemmas. Should you tip if the service isn’t great? Is it okay to hold back because your order was late or your food wasn’t exactly right? And what about tipping when you’re abroad—what’s the “right” thing to do? Let’s break it down in a way that won’t make your head spin.

Tipping Around the World

First off, tipping customs are all over the place depending on where you are. In some countries, it’s just a nice extra; in others, it’s almost mandatory. For example, in the U.S., tipping is a big deal—servers rely on it because their wages are often pretty low. In Japan, however, tipping can actually be seen as rude, since good service is already expected as part of the job.

In the UK, a new law makes sure that when you do tip, it goes directly to the service staff. But no, you’re not forced to tip—it’s still your choice, just like in most places.

In South Africa, tipping is a common practice, and it’s usual to leave around 10-15% of your bill in restaurants. Service staff often rely on tips to boost their earnings, much like in the U.S. So while it’s not required by law, it’s definitely expected in most places, especially in tourist-heavy areas.

Meanwhile, in places like France or Italy, they sometimes include a “service charge” in the bill, so tipping is more of a bonus if you feel like leaving one.

What About Bad Service?

So what do you do when the service just isn’t up to scratch? We’ve all been there—waiting too long for your food, dealing with a distracted server, or having your order come out wrong. The first reaction might be to skip the tip entirely. After all, isn’t tipping for good service?

Well, not always. Sometimes the bad service isn’t the waiter’s fault. Maybe the kitchen was slammed, or they’re short-staffed, or your server is just having a rough day. It happens. So, does that mean you have to tip no matter what? Not really. It’s your call, but here are a few things to think about:

1. What’s Really Going On?: If the service is slow because the place is packed or the kitchen’s backed up, it might not be your server’s fault. You could leave a smaller tip, but maybe not skip it entirely.

2. Give Feedback: If you’re really unhappy, try mentioning it before making a decision about the tip. Often, a server or manager will try to make things right if they know there’s a problem.

3. Leave a Small Tip: Some people leave a smaller tip—say 5%—to show that the service wasn’t great, but still acknowledge the effort.

4. Follow Local Customs: When you’re abroad, it’s good to know the local tipping customs. In some places, not tipping can be seen as rude, but in others, tipping too much can be confusing.

It’s Not Always Black and White

Tipping isn’t an exact science. It’s up to you how much (or if) you want to tip, based on the service and your experience. But try to keep in mind that service workers have tough jobs, and sometimes a little tip goes a long way. If the service wasn’t perfect but you can tell your waiter was doing their best, a tip—no matter how small—can still show appreciation.

Tipping is all about balance. When in doubt, go with the flow of the local customs wherever you are.