Posted on by Chesney

Plagiarists deserve punishment but what about those who get away with it

Share these new ideas

Designed by PixelCrafters

Plagiarism is an evil that pervades all sorts of written work. It’s not the same as stealing someone’s ideas. Ideas not in the form of writing or a product or service are stolen all the time. When it comes to written work, it’s a serious offense. There is a definite reason for this. People who write documents put a lot of effort into their research. They have original ideas and they work hard to communicate their information, whether it be infotainment, academic research, or fiction. To be a victim of plagiarism is a terrible thing. You lose your trust in the other party, the perpetrator. You never forget what the plagiarist has done to you. Many plagiarists don’t get caught. Often it’s only the celebrated writers and academics that are exposed. Let’s look at some of the interesting plagiarism cases in this country and further afield.

In South Africa, some well-known cases of plagiarism include:

  1. Eugène Marais and Maurice Maeterlinck – This is one of the most famous historical cases. Eugène Marais, a South African naturalist, and poet wrote extensively about termites, particularly in his work The Soul of the White Ant. Belgian author Maurice Maeterlinck later published The Life of the White Ant, which contained striking similarities to Marais’s work. Marais accused Maeterlinck of plagiarism, but the case was never officially resolved.
  2. David Bullard – The well-known journalist and columnist for The Sunday Times was accused of plagiarism in 2008. Bullard had lifted substantial parts of his column from an article published in The Spectator in 2006. This led to significant backlash and eventually to his dismissal from The Sunday Times.
  3. Another well-known case of plagiarism involving a Sunday Times columnist in South Africa is that of Pearlie Joubert. In 2007, Joubert, a prominent journalist and columnist, was accused of plagiarism when it was discovered that some of her articles contained unattributed material from other sources. This incident drew significant attention in South African media and raised concerns about journalistic integrity.
  4. In 2002, South African columnist and author Darrel Bristow-Bovey was accused of plagiarizing material from American humorist Bill Bryson in his columns for The Cape Times and The Sunday Independent. The scandal led to Bristow-Bovey being dismissed from The Cape Times and facing significant damage to his reputation. Further accusations arose when parts of his book I Moved Your Cheese were also found to contain uncredited material from Bryson’s work. This high-profile case highlighted the importance of originality and proper attribution in journalism and writing.

Here are some recent examples of plagiarism in South Africa:

  1. Katlego Maboe – In 2021, TV presenter Katlego Maboe faced allegations of plagiarism when a social media post he shared was found to have been copied from another source without proper attribution. The incident added to the controversies surrounding him at the time.
  2. Busisiwe Mkhwebane – The Public Protector of South Africa, Busisiwe Mkhwebane, was accused of plagiarism in 2019. It was alleged that significant portions of her report on the South African Reserve Bank and the financial aid provided to Absa bank were directly copied from a document by an outside legal expert without proper citation.
  3. Mcebo Dlamini – In 2016, former Wits University SRC president Mcebo Dlamini was accused of plagiarizing parts of his master’s research proposal. The allegations came during a tumultuous period marked by the #FeesMustFall protests, and they drew significant attention to academic integrity issues within the student leadership.
  4. Simphiwe Dana – In 2020, singer Simphiwe Dana was accused of plagiarism when portions of her open letter about gender-based violence were found to have been copied from an article by another author without appropriate credit. Dana later apologized for the oversight.

These cases underscore the ongoing challenges of maintaining academic and journalistic integrity in South Africa, reflecting the broader global issue of intellectual property rights and ethical writing practices.

Several academic plagiarism cases in South Africa have attracted significant attention:

  1. Pallo Jordan – Although not a direct case of plagiarism, former Minister of Arts and Culture Pallo Jordan was found in 2014 to have falsified his academic credentials, claiming to have a doctorate from the London School of Economics. This scandal involved academic dishonesty and led to his resignation from various positions.
  2. Ethics Investigation at Stellenbosch University – In 2017, Stellenbosch University conducted an investigation into allegations of plagiarism involving several staff members in the Department of Mechanical and Mechatronic Engineering. The case revolved around research articles published in academic journals that contained substantial unattributed material.
  3. Mcebo Dlamini – Former Wits University SRC president Mcebo Dlamini was accused in 2016 of plagiarizing parts of his master’s research proposal. This incident raised significant concerns about academic integrity within the student leadership during the #FeesMustFall protests.
  4. Walter Sisulu University – In 2018, Walter Sisulu University faced a major scandal when it was revealed that several senior academics, including deans and professors, had been involved in widespread plagiarism. The investigation found that many academic papers published by these staff members contained unattributed material from various sources.
  5. Unisa (University of South Africa) – In 2020, Unisa dealt with a significant plagiarism scandal involving a senior academic who was found to have copied large sections of another scholar’s work in their research publications. This case led to calls for stricter measures to ensure academic integrity within the institution.

These cases highlight the ongoing challenges of maintaining academic integrity in South Africa and the importance of robust mechanisms to detect and address plagiarism in academic institutions.

Several high-profile plagiarism cases have garnered significant attention over the years. Here are some of the most notable ones:

  1. Jayson Blair – In 2003, The New York Times reporter Jayson Blair was found to have fabricated stories and plagiarized material from other publications. The scandal led to his resignation and a major internal review at the newspaper.
  2. Jonah Lehrer – The writer and journalist was accused of recycling his own material and fabricating quotes in his books, including Imagine and How We Decide. Lehrer resigned from The New Yorker in 2012 following these revelations.
  3. Kaavya Viswanathan – In 2006, the Harvard student and author of How Opal Mehta Got Kissed, Got Wild, and Got a Life was found to have plagiarized passages from several young adult novels. The book was eventually pulled from shelves.
  4. Joe Biden – During his 1988 presidential campaign, Biden was accused of plagiarizing parts of a speech by British Labour Party leader Neil Kinnock. This controversy led to Biden withdrawing from the race.
  5. Melania Trump – In 2016, Melania Trump’s speech at the Republican National Convention was found to have striking similarities to Michelle Obama’s 2008 Democratic National Convention speech.
  6. Alex Haley – The author of Roots, a Pulitzer Prize-winning novel, faced accusations of plagiarism from Harold Courlander’s The African. Haley settled the case out of court.
  7. Fareed Zakaria – The journalist and author faced plagiarism allegations in 2012 when it was discovered that parts of his column in Time magazine closely mirrored a piece from The New Yorker. Zakaria was briefly suspended but later reinstated.
  8. Doris Kearns Goodwin – The historian and author admitted to using passages from other works without proper attribution in her book The Fitzgeralds and the Kennedys. She reached a settlement with the author whose work she had plagiarized.

These cases highlight the importance of originality and proper attribution in writing and the severe consequences that can arise from failing to adhere to these principles.

People plagiarize for various reasons, often influenced by a combination of personal, academic, and societal factors. Here are some common reasons:

  1. Pressure to Succeed: Academic and professional environments can create intense pressure to achieve high grades, publish frequently, or meet tight deadlines. This pressure can lead individuals to cut corners by copying others’ work.
  2. Lack of Understanding: Some individuals may not fully understand what constitutes plagiarism or how to properly cite sources. This lack of knowledge can lead to unintentional plagiarism.
  3. Poor Time Management: Procrastination and poor time management skills can result in last-minute rushes to complete assignments or projects, leading some to plagiarize as a quick solution.
  4. Perceived Low Risk: The belief that they won’t get caught can encourage some individuals to plagiarize. If they perceive the chances of detection and consequences as low, they might consider it a viable option.
  5. Academic and Professional Ambition: The desire to achieve academic recognition, secure scholarships, or advance in one’s career can motivate individuals to plagiarize to present themselves as more accomplished than they are.
  6. Laziness or Lack of Effort: Some people might plagiarize because they are unwilling to put in the effort required to produce original work. They might find it easier to copy someone else’s work rather than doing their own research and writing.
  7. Inadequate Writing Skills: Individuals who feel insecure about their writing abilities may plagiarize to present a higher quality of work than they believe they can produce on their own.
  8. Cultural Factors: In some cultures, the concept of intellectual property may not be as strongly emphasized, leading individuals to view the use of others’ work without proper attribution as more acceptable.
  9. Access to Technology: The ease of access to information and the ability to copy and paste from digital sources can make plagiarism more tempting and straightforward.
  10. Lack of Consequences: In environments where plagiarism is not strictly monitored or penalized, individuals may feel more inclined to plagiarize without fear of significant repercussions.

Understanding these motivations can help educators, institutions, and organizations develop more effective strategies to prevent and address plagiarism, such as promoting academic integrity, providing clear guidelines on proper citation, and fostering a culture of original work and ethical behavior.

To ensure you don’t accidentally plagiarize someone’s work, follow these best practices:

  1. Understand Plagiarism: Familiarize yourself with what constitutes plagiarism, including direct copying, paraphrasing without credit, and using someone else’s ideas without proper acknowledgment.
  2. Proper Citation: Always cite sources when you use ideas, quotes, data, or any information that is not your own. Use the appropriate citation style (e.g., APA, MLA, Chicago) as required by your academic or professional context.
  3. Keep Detailed Notes: When researching, keep detailed notes of the sources you consult, including page numbers, authors, publication dates, and any other relevant information. This will make it easier to cite correctly later.
  4. Use Quotation Marks: If you use someone else’s exact words, enclose them in quotation marks and provide an appropriate citation. This clearly distinguishes the original author’s words from your own.
  5. Paraphrase Effectively: When paraphrasing, rewrite the original idea in your own words and style, not just by changing a few words. Even when paraphrasing, you must still cite the original source.
  6. Use Plagiarism Detection Tools: Utilize plagiarism detection software like Turnitin, Grammarly, or other online tools to check your work for any unintentional copying before submission.
  7. Reference All Sources: Include a comprehensive bibliography or works cited page at the end of your document, listing all the sources you consulted and cited in your work.
  8. Seek Permission for Images and Media: If you use images, charts, or other media, ensure you have the right to use them and provide appropriate attribution. Some materials may require explicit permission from the copyright holder.
  9. Consult Style Guides: Refer to style guides (e.g., APA, MLA, Chicago) for proper citation formats and guidelines. Many educational institutions provide resources and guides on how to cite sources correctly.
  10. Review and Revise: Review your work carefully to ensure that all sources are properly cited and that you haven’t unintentionally used someone else’s words or ideas without acknowledgment.
  11. Seek Guidance: If you are unsure about how to cite a source or whether something constitutes plagiarism, seek guidance from a teacher, professor, or writing center.

By being diligent and following these practices, you can significantly reduce the risk of accidental plagiarism and ensure that you are respecting intellectual property rights.

Disclaimer

This blog post has used artificial intelligence for research of well-known instances of plagiarism. The information was correct at the time of publishing. Only known sources were used. The author takes no responsibility whatsoever for any factual information from published sources which in themselves may be incorrect. Please consult your own references. if you require advice on plagiarism, speak to an expert and even get legal advice.

Ensure Your Business Documents Shine!

As a business professional, it’s crucial to present your best self in all written communications. An experienced editor like myself can refine your documents, enhancing clarity and impact. Strong writing is essential for effective selling and marketing. Contact me to help you put your best foot forward in all your business documents!